So the only honest way to do it was to close the account. Take the money out as a nonqualified withdrawal and pay what that costs.
What that costs is the income tax on the earnings, plus a ten percent federal penalty on the earnings. And Missouri takes back the state deductions it let me take on the contributions over the years.
I ran it three times on the legal pad. It came to a little over six thousand dollars, all told. Six thousand dollars of my own money, gone to taxes, to make the move.
I sat on that tailgate and watched the sun go down over the hayfield, and I thought about the twenty-five dollars a week I put in when I was twenty-five and eating ramen noodles.
Neil walked out from the house and leaned on the tailgate beside me. He looked at the legal pad. He did not need me to explain it. He is good with numbers.
Get a new story in your inbox every morning.
Facebook doesn’t show you every story we post. Our free newsletter does. Join 2,500+ readers.
“You sure?” he asked.
“I’m sure,” I said. “It’s not about the joke. I need you to know that. If Hunter had never said a word, I’d still want this boy to have something.”
“I know,” Neil said. “But the joke didn’t hurt.”
I laughed for the first time that whole week. He put his arm around me, and we sat there until the mosquitoes ran us off.
Why I did not just call
People have asked me since why I did not call Jeff that night in July and have it out with him. Or why I did not tell him in September what I was about to do.
The honest answer is that the account was in my name and the money was mine. I did not need a fight at the farm. I needed that money to go to the boy who needed it.
If I had called Jeff, he would have made a joke. That is what he does. And then I would have had to listen to it, and then I would have had to decide again.
I had already decided. I had decided on a tailgate at the edge of a hayfield, with a legal pad and my husband beside me, sober and calm. That was good enough for me.
The paperwork
The first week of October, I took a morning off from the lab and did it. I filled out the withdrawal form and had the check sent to me.
I paid the estimated tax right then so it would not sneak up on me in April.
Karen helped me get Brody’s Social Security number so I could open the new account. She had to check with her supervisor first. She called back and said, “They said it’s fine. They said it’s more than fine.”
I opened a new Missouri 529 account with me as the owner and Brody as the beneficiary. Thirty-eight thousand nine hundred dollars went into it that afternoon.
I set up the same automatic deposit I had always had. Fifty dollars a week.
When I drove home that day, I went the long way, past the farm. I could see Jeff’s truck out by the pasture and the cattle bunched up near the water tank. I did not stop.