The Four Words I Wrote Every Time

“Mom said it on the step. When it didn’t come through.” He shrugged. “And she says it on the phone to Aunt Kim. She says at least you pay.”

I pushed the bag back into his pocket and closed his hand over it.

“You keep that. That is yours, for the crabapples. Now listen to me. You never, ever have to pay for me. Not one nickel. That is grown-up business, and the grown-ups are going to fix it.”

“When?”

A child will ask you the one question you do not have an answer to.

“Soon,” I said.

I did not wait until I got home. I did not wait until Sunday. I walked that boy back to the living room, turned on his cartoons, and went straight into the kitchen, where Tiffany was wiping down a counter that was already clean.

“He knows,” I said. I kept my voice low. “He just tried to give me three dollars and forty cents out of his pocket so I could come back Thursday.”

Her hand stopped on the dishrag.

“I have never said one word to him about money,” I said. “He heard it from you. Whatever this is between you and me, Tiffany, I have gone along with it. But he is seven years old. He is out of it, starting today.”

For just a second something moved in her face. Then it was gone, and she started wiping again.

“Then pay on time,” she said, “and he won’t have anything to hear.”

I sat in my car in front of their house until my hands were steady enough to drive six blocks.

Two weeks later I paid the fourteenth. I typed the four words. I did it because the other choice was a little boy deciding he had not saved up fast enough.


Our school holds its own Grandparents Day on the first Friday of October. They moved it there years ago, into the gap when most of the farm grandpas can get away from a combine for two hours.

Twenty-two of us came. We sat on first-grade chairs, which put our knees up around our ribs. Big men in seed caps held paper cups of Kool-Aid with two fingers. Don Halvorson was two chairs down from me, there for his grandson. The room smelled like crayons and floor wax, exactly as it did when Scott sat in it.

It was the same room, and the same teacher. Mrs. Ortman had Scott in first grade thirty years ago. She has taught half this town to read.

She had the children sit on the rug, and she told us they had each been practicing one sentence all week.

“Each of our friends is going to stand up,” she said, “and tell us one special thing about the grandparent who came today.”

A little girl said her grandma makes lefse and lets her turn it with the stick. Don’s grandson said his grandpa drives a combine as big as a house and lets him honk the horn.

Then it was Mason’s turn.

He stood up very straight. He had on the plaid shirt with the pearl snaps that I gave him for his birthday. He found me on my little chair and he smiled, proud as anything. He thought he was about to give me a present.

“This is my Grandma Carol Ann,” he said, loud and clear, the way they had practiced. “The special thing about my grandma is she has to pay fifty dollars every time she comes to our house. And she pays it every time. And she never even gets mad.”

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *