Mariah Carey is nominated for the 2026 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. So is Wu-Tang Clan. Shakira. Lauryn Hill. If you’re currently formulating a “but are they rock” argument in your head, congratulations, you’re doing exactly what the Hall of Fame wants you to do right now.
This is the game they’ve been running for years and honestly it works. Pick nominees that generate argument, watch the internet fight about genre definitions for two weeks, collect the cultural relevance that comes from people caring enough to be upset. A museum that nobody argues about is a museum nobody visits. The Rock Hall figured that out and they’re not going back.
The debate this year is particularly interesting, more than it usually is. Wu-Tang Clan’s cultural footprint is enormous and their fanbase is not the type to sit quietly while the institution takes its time. Oasis is back on the list for the third time after being snubbed enough times that their eventual induction feels more like when than if. Melissa Etheridge, Phil Collins, Sade, P!NK. There’s enough range in this class that almost any music fan has someone to get behind or get annoyed about. The full list of 17 nominees also includes Jeff Buckley, INXS, Iron Maiden, Joy Division/New Order, New Edition, Billy Idol, Luther Vandross, and The Black Crowes.
Get a new story in your inbox every morning.
Facebook doesn’t show you every story we post. Our free newsletter does. Join 2,500+ readers.
The fan vote is real and it matters more than people who don’t follow this closely tend to assume. It doesn’t pick the final class but it shapes the conversation and signals to the voting committee what the public actually cares about. The campaigns are going to be loud this cycle.
Personally I think Lauryn Hill should have been in years ago and the fact that she’s still a nominee rather than an inductee is its own kind of statement. The inductees will be announced in April. Until then, the argument is the entertainment.
If you want to vote: the fan vote is open now at rockhall.com. It counts as one ballot among the 1,200 cast by industry professionals but it shapes the conversation and the Rock Hall pays attention to it.
If you have a strong opinion about who belongs: the inductees will be announced in April. Between now and then the campaigns, the arguments, and the think pieces are all part of the event.
Bottom line: the Rock Hall is not really about rock anymore. It is about music that mattered. Whether that’s a good thing depends entirely on who you think should be in the room.